Home / In the news / Press releases

Gordon Brown and Rowan Williams warn that churches and other warm community hubs like pubs face closure this winter unless government takes ‘honest’ approach

Gordon Brown and Rowan Williams warn that churches and other warm community hubs like pubs face closure this winter unless government takes ‘honest’ approach

UNDER EMBARGO until Monday 7th November 09.00 

Gordon Brown and Rowan Williams warn that churches and other warm community hubs like pubs face closure this winter unless government takes ‘honest’ approach 

– Further crisis unless Rishi Sunak’s Government acts to help ‘last line of defence’ against cost of living crisis, new report shows 

– Former prime minister and Archbishop of Canterbury warn: ‘Society is judged by how it treats its most vulnerable members’ 

Churches and community hubs – including pubs – are threatened by closure this winter because ‘they cannot afford to keep the lights on’ unless the new UK government makes urgent reforms such as exemption from business rates, a new report shows. 

The idea that churches and similar buildings might operate as ‘warm banks’ for vulnerable people is now under threat, according to the report, which has a joint foreword by the former Prime Minister Gordon Brown and the former Archbishop of Canterbury Rowan Williams. 

These community institutions form a vital part of the safety net offering security and material support to millions of people but are now themselves becoming less secure, the report demonstrates. 

Mr Brown and Dr Williams say: ‘What we are waiting to hear from the latest administration in Westminster is whether this urgency is recognised, and whether there is enough honesty about the problem and enough willingness to find a solution.  Britain’s safety net is torn. So much is clear from this report.  We dare to hope that it is not torn beyond repair; but that is up to public as well as private vision and generosity.’ 

The cost of living and economic crises, on top of the Covid–19 pandemic and Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, now pose a threat not only to individual circumstances, but to the fabric of civil society and faith groups.  

Tax breaks for volunteers and linking giving to the rate of inflation are among other proposals in the report aimed at relieving the social crisis at the heart of communities.  

The new report by the Christian think tank Theos, A torn safety net: How the cost of living crisis threatens its own last line of defence, is based on extensive research and dozens of interviews with key community figures this year concentrated in Wolverhampton, Glasgow, Cornwall and London. 

It says: ‘There is a risk that churches and other faith groups will close, not because of falling attendance or religious affiliation, but because they cannot afford to keep the lights on.’  

The report found that without action to address rising bills, the financial sustainability of buildings such as churches themselves will be threatened, and it is not only faith institutions which will be at risk of being lost as a result, but also community hubs such as pubs as well and scout huts, all of which are subject to business rates for utilities.  

‘The safety net of charities and community groups which offer security to those in precarious circumstances is now at risk,’ the report says. ‘If the effects of this are not addressed effectively, it is possible that valuable institutions like churches may shut, leaving economic and social scars on the community.’ 

The report’s author, Hannah Rich, a senior researcher at Theos, describes the situation as a ‘perfect storm’ for communities. She says: ‘As the economy has spiralled, we have seen these anchor institutions themselves become less secure. Soaring energy costs threaten the ability to run vital community spaces. At the same time, volunteer capacity is stretched thin and financial donations are drying up. It is a perfect storm.’ 

The report argues that a new ‘social recession’ has emerged in local communities as a result of four key dimensions of insecurity: income and employment, housing, access to food, and migration status.  

As well as the energy price cap for community hubs, Theos makes a series of recommendations, including: 

– A tax break for volunteering time, which has retreated, as well as greater employer support for paid volunteering leave and changes in the tax code for paying petrol and other expenses to volunteers. 

– Helping charities and churches and people who generously give to them by raising the rate of Gift Aid on charitable donations, with an increase for groups being able to claim an extra 25p for every £1 donated by a taxpayer to 30p or more.  

– A link between giving with the rate of inflation for organisations and congregations reliant on regular giving via direct debit. 

Theos also argues that it should be made easier for local communities and faith groups to invest in assets like housing for local residents. The Charities Act 2011 requires charitable organisations selling land or property to achieve the best possible price for it, unless there are compelling reasons otherwise. This means charities and churches are often forced to sell to corporate developers, and the resulting properties are unaffordable for local community members.  


Note to editors: 

1. This report is informed by a series of 48 semi–structured interviews conducted by Theos researchers between January and August 2022. These were concentrated in four local authority areas: Cornwall, Glasgow, Wolverhampton, and the London borough of Newham. These areas were selected based on data for various indicators of insecurity, including metrics for housing, debt and (un)employment, as well as covering both urban and rural areas. Additionally, Theos interviewed a number of individuals from outside these geographical areas, chosen because of their experience and expertise of particular aspects of insecurity and religion.  

2. For more information, or to arrange an interview please contact Hannah Rich (Senior Researcher and Author) on 07917 433 624 or or Lizzie Harvey (Head of Communications, Theos) on 07778 160 052  


Interested in this? Share it on social media. Join our monthly e–newsletter to keep up to date with our latest research and events. And check out our Supporter Programme to find out how you can help our work.

Hannah Rich

Hannah Rich

Hannah joined Theos in 2017. She is a senior researcher working on theology and economic inequality. She is the author of ‘A Torn Safety Net’ (2022).

Watch, listen to or read more from Hannah Rich

Posted 4 November 2022


See all

In the news

See all


See all

Get regular email updates on our latest research and events.

Please confirm your subscription in the email we have sent you.

Want to keep up to date with the latest news, reports, blogs and events from Theos? Get updates direct to your inbox once or twice a month.

Thank you for signing up.